Who is Gideon Sa'ar, Israel's touted right-wing kingmaker?

Who is Gideon Sa'ar, Israel's touted right-wing kingmaker?
An unlikely kingmaker has emerged in Israeli politics following reports of growing tensions between PM Benjamin Netanyahu and Defence Minister Yoav Gallant.
4 min read
30 September, 2024
Gideon Sa'ar and Benjamin Netanyahu have put differences behind them... for now [Getty]

Two weeks ago, shocking news emerged that Gideo Sa'ar could replace Yoav Gallant as defence minister and return to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's unity government.

Sa'ar was once heralded as a new force in Israel right-wing politics and one of the biggest threats to Netanyahu's decades-long grip on power. The formation of his right-wing New Hope party, however, failed to live up to expectations.

While not appointed defence minister, on Monday Sa'ar was named a new minister without portfolio and a member of the war cabinet with promises of a more prominent role in government in the future.

As ever, the prudent Netanyahu appears to have out-foxed Sa'ar, who has languished on the sidelines of Israeli politics in recent months, as well as his far-right associates within Likud.

Who is Gideon Sa'ar?

Sa'ar is one of Netanyahu's foremost right-wing opponents, whose recent foray into politics follows a successful career in law.

Born to Ashkenazi Jewish parents in Tel Aviv, Sa'ar served in Israeli military as an intelligence officer in the Golani Brigade, before studying law at university.

He worked with the Attorney General playing an influential role in the implementation of several key laws, along with advisory roles in Netanyahu's government.

Sa'ar entered competitive politics in 2003, when he was elected as an MK with Netanyahu's right-wing Likud and rapidly ascended the ranks of the party, serving as minister of education from 2009 to 2013.

Shortly after being appointed minister of interior, Sa'ar dramatically quit the Knesset in 2014 but this was to prove to be a mere hiatus, and he returned to active Likud politics in 2017, before being appointed by Netanyahu as justice minister.

He left Likud in 2020 forming the New Hope splinter party, promising to end Netanyahu's "cult of personality" and provide an alternative for right-wing Israelis.

What is his relationship with Netanyahu?

As soon as Sa'ar returned to Israeli politics, he was primed as a possible challenger to scandal-ridden Netanyahu as head of the Likud Party and had an acrimonious relationship with the prime minister.

His New Hope party was never able to replicate the successes many on the right of Israeli politics hoped for, and through stunning alliances and brinkmanship, Netanyahu was to remain in power.

Netanyahu's alliance with the far-right has been rocky, with the ultra-Orthodox recruitment bill being one issue causing divisions within his Likud Party.

The prime minister was reportedly ready to sack Gallant over his support for drafting ultra-Orthodox Jews into the army - an issue that could bring down the government due to far-right, ultra-Orthodox parties strongly opposing such changes to this arrangement, which has seen Haredi religious students avoid military service.

While Gallant remains defence minister, Netanyahu is said to be considering replacing him with Sa'ar at a later date, who could drop his previous opposition to the ultra-Orthodox being exempted from compulsary military service.

The pair appeared to put their differences behind them at a press conference on Monday and said they would endeavour to put Israel's wars in Gaza and Lebanon above individual political bickering.

Sa'ar's re-entry into government has effectively isolated him from the Israeli opposition and broadened Netanyahu's appeal among the secular right.

How might it affect Gaza and Lebanon?

Sa'ar  is widely considered a hawk on security and foreign affairs, in many ways to the right of Netanyahu who, despite his ruthless streak,  has at times displayed some pragmatism.

Sa'ar strongly opposed Ariel Sharon's disengagement plan for Gaza, and has blamed the withdrawal of Israeli settlers and troops there for the 7 October attacks.

He has indicated that a continued troop presence in Gaza is essential for Israel's security and this would fit with Netanyahu's demand for maintaining control of the Philadelphi Corridor, an outcome opposed by some even within Likud.

The appointment of Sa'ar comes amid an anticipated Israeli ground invasion of southern Lebanon - likely overseen by Gallant - following a massive intensification of an aerial campaign against the country, which has killed over 1,000 Lebanese and displaced 1 million.

The addition of a hardliner such as Sa'ar to the war cabinet will likely strengthen Netanyahu's 'tough man' image and appeal to secular nationalists. 

Sa'ar said on Monday that Israel's intensified attacks on Lebanon and Yemen is a “distinctly active approach I have always supported".