No alternative to risky oil tanker salvage in Yemen, UN says

Transferring more than a million barrels of oil from an abandoned tanker anchored off the shore of Yemen comes with "palpable risks" - but doing nothing could lead to a devastating oil spill, a senior UN official said Wednesday.

"If something were to go wrong, indeed, many questions will be asked," said Achim Steiner, head of the United Nations Development Program, which is in charge of salvage of the FSO Safer, underway since Tuesday.

But "walking away is not an option," he told AFP in an interview.

The 47-year-old ship is carrying four times as much oil as that which spilled in the 1989 Exxon Valdez disaster off Alaska, one of the world's worst ecological catastrophes.

And the Safer hasn't been serviced since Yemen's civil war broke out in 2015 - left abandoned off the rebel-held port of Hodeida, a critical gateway for shipments into the war-torn country, which is heavily dependent on foreign aid.

This is what the #FSOSafer looks like today. For years, its status was unknown.

Now, marine salvage experts from @beleefboskalis have boarded the ship & testing and inspections continue to assess the vessel's state.

Another step forward in @UN-led operation to #StopRedSeaSpill pic.twitter.com/EmKVEx97Cd

— Achim Steiner (@ASteiner) June 2, 2023

To unload the Safer's oil - a process set to begin in less than two weeks - the United Nations had to purchase its own super-tanker. Private company SMIT Salvage will pump the oil from the Safer to the UN-owned ship, called Nautica, and then tow away the empty tanker.

The first images sent from the site this week revealed "an old, rusty tanker," Steiner said.

Experts who mounted the ship Wednesday didn't immediately find "anything that we did not expect," though those in charge are still waiting for a full evaluation.

In the meantime, the Safer remains a ticking time bomb.

"The most catastrophic scenario could be that the vessel explodes or that indeed it falls apart, it develops some major oil spill," Steiner said.

A spill - "increasingly viewed as an inevitable risk" - could cost up to $20 billion to clean up, to say nothing of the environmental and human toll, and the UN is negotiating with an insurance consortium to insure the operation.

We began the operation to remove the oil from #FSOSafer, a decaying supertanker moored off Yemen's coast, threatening a humanitarian & environmental disaster.

Thanks to many partners, incl. #EU 🇪🇺 and #TeamEurope 🇳🇱 🇩🇪 🇸🇪 🇫🇷 🇮🇹🇩🇰🇫🇮🇱🇺🇬🇷🇲🇹🇨🇾 for supporting this critical operation. pic.twitter.com/S5DIj8o31d

— UNDP at EU (@UNDPEU) May 31, 2023

A potential payday 

One of the first steps will be securing the ship, whose onboard systems are no longer operational. Then, SMIT Salvage will need "to pump inert gas into the tanks, which significantly reduces the risk of an explosion or fire."

But the UN is preparing for the worst, with "a contingency plan that extends well beyond the site of the Safer" and has to take into account the risks potentially posed by landmines onshore.

In addition to the insurance consortium, the UN team had to navigate a coterie of lawyers and experts - and the warring parties in Yemen -- to secure an accord to safely unload the Safer's deadly cargo.

But the world body is still $29 million short in what it estimates will be a more than $140 million project.

Even when the oil is pumped out -- a process that could be finished by early or mid-July -- Steiner won't be able to rest easy.

Pumping is only good for getting the actual liquid oil out. But "over the years, a kind of sludge builds up at the bottom of the tanks," which will take a specialized SMIT Salvage team to clear.

"That sludge is not insignificant in terms of its potential impact that it could have on marine biodiversity" or the health of the Yemeni people, Steiner said.

The job will only finish when the Safer is finally towed to a scrap yard.

But while the ship's contents currently represent a massive risk, it is possible the oil could bring about a sizable windfall.

"There could be significant revenues in the tens of millions of dollars" if it's not contaminated by sea water or other substances, Steiner said.

"The oil... could actually be sold so that that revenue could be used to help people in Yemen who are desperate, fighting for their survival."

It's still a long way to payday, however, as the parties to the conflict in Yemen need to agree on how to use the potential revenues.

The UN "will continue to engage" with the sides "and hopefully arrive at that conclusion that everybody will buy into," Steiner said.